Sorry, the last post was a bit dramatic. No, they don’t string the kids up and whip them. But, no, the program is not appropriate for three-to-four year olds.
I recorded every detail. This may put you in a bored stupor, and I'm not even done. My suggestion? Scan it for the interesting parts. You have been warned.
Because this happened in the public school, I plan to meet with the principal. That’s why I wanted to write it all down. By next week, I will have boiled this all down in my brain so I can speak to him coherently and not rattle on like I'm about to here.
The last post left me sitting by the computers, offering me a fly-on-the-wall view of circle time.
8:32: The kids come in with their parents, hang their coats and head over to the semi-circle, where they find their name on a 12”x12” vinyl mat on the floor, and sit. They may not pick up a toy or a book, they may not stray from their mat.
Within a minute, the Meanie discovers Michael* playing with a toy alligator he got off the shelf behind him. “No! Put that back. You know better,” she admonishes, pulling the toy from his hands.
The kids sit, silent, and wait.
8:40: The Teacher finds her way over to her chair to hold court over the circle, while the Assistant and the Meanie sit on chairs on either side. I stare at the Teacher, expecting her to acknowledge me: a smile, a nod, eye contact –
something! But she ignores me, which pisses me off. She never even tells the children who I am, so every once in a while I get wide-eyed stares, which I answer with a broad smile and a little wave.
Circle time begins with roll call. The teacher calls each name and the children answer, “Hi!”
The third girl, Sarah, says, “Hi!” Pause. “Hi!”
“Only once, Sarah,” the Teacher tells her. No room for spontaneous hello’s here.
8:45: The Teacher chitchats about different things (who’s back from being sick, how's he feeling, who’s out today) to the kids, who sit and listen. The Teacher, the Assistant and the Meanie start small talking with each other. The kids wait.
8:50: Everyone stands for the pledge of allegiance. The Teacher talks about the calendar and the weather and assigns various jobs. One is for an “office helper,” who gets to choose a friend to walk to the office with him. John’s upset that the office helper doesn't choose him, despite his please of “Choose me! Choose
me!” (He tells me later that in five weeks he never got to go to the office.) The office pair leaves the class unsupervised (?), returning full of giggles a few minutes later. This was the only giggling I heard during my visit.
The Teacher says certain words to certain kids and asks them to repeat them. (This is a public preschool with some developmentally delayed kids.)
Twenty minutes in and the kids are still quiet, listening, sitting on their squares, speaking only when spoken to. I’m creeped out by the still, silent three and four year olds, and and I’m so bored by the teacher’s pace and saccharine monotone that I find myself checking the clock every minute.
From my vantage point, John appears to be sitting still, too, but since 9:30 the Assistant has whispered to him three different times. The third time he plasters his hands over his ears.
I realize John won’t be back and contemplate leaving. I don't, though, because I told John I’d stay until snack time, and I don’t want to upset him. Plus, I may as well stay and see what I can see.
8:55: The children stand, and the Teacher plays Raffi’s “Shake Your Sillies Out.” (They do this every day, I know because it’s the only thing John’s mentioned doing in school besides Rescue Heroes.) John gets spoken to for wiggling off his mat. He stands when instructed to fall to the floor, and falls when told to stand. His last bit of defiance.
9:00: The “Language Arts” Specialist takes over. The Meanie tells the kids to, “Go to your seats and sit with your hands folded.” They go, unsmiling.
9:00-9:20: The kids paste pictures into a book. “Pick up the mom, paste her here; pick up the dad, paste him there; pick up the bear ...” This is not an exercise in creative expression.
The Teacher approaches John. “You didn’t put enough glue,” she says, grabbing his glue stick. “The picture will fall right out!” She smears a bunch of glue on the white page, sticks the picture on and tells John to press it down. John – my John who insists on doing
everything himself and barely even let me feed him as a baby – looks pissed but doesn’t say a word.
The Specialist comes by and tells John he’s doing it wrong, he should put the glue on the back of the picture, not on the book’s page, as the Teacher told him. In a normal setting, John would have said, “Well, the other teacher told me to do it this way.” But he says nothing.
With the books finished, a few kids begin to stand but are shushed and directed back to their seats. The Teacher reads the book while the kids look bored and distracted, then instructs them to put their books into their back packs.
As he walks to his cubby, Michael stretches his arms out at his sides, like an airplane, but not all the way up. The Teacher’s right on top of him. “Arms down!” He complies, but runs a few steps while going back to his seat. “No running, Michael!” the Meanie says tersely.
9:20: The Teacher sends the kids back to their square mats. They first to arrive must wait for the others to get there and for story time to start. (
Sit, quiet, wait.)
Michael’s sitting on the bench next to Julie. They’re playing, pulling each other’s arms. The Meanie notices and tells them to stop it. “Michael, THAT’S not where you were sitting, get on your assigned mat.” She sounds very disgusted. “You, too, Julie. Let’s go.”
I’m disgusted too.
Within a minute, Michael’s in trouble again, “Don’t do
that, don’t put that in your mouth,” Meanie tells him. I can’t see what he’s doing. “HEY!” she snaps, leaning in, glaring, getting her mean on. “Don’t you make a face at me,” she hisses. “When I say don’t do something you say, ‘OK.’” She changes her tone from mean to sweet with the OK, which only serves to punctuate just how mean she sounded to begin with.
I scowl at her. She doesn’t look at me, though I will her to.
*All names have, of course, been changed.Coming in Part 3: Story time (ssshhh!), snack time (more sitting and waiting) and my exit, graceful as always. Plus! John's in tears when I pick him up, again!